What It Means to Be an American: Then and Now

The identity of an American has evolved over centuries, shaped by historical events, cultural diversity, and shifting societal values. What it means to be an American now differs in many ways from what it meant in the past. In this essay, we will explore the dynamic nature of American identity, tracing its evolution from the nation's founding to the present day.

Historical Foundations of American Identity

America's identity was forged in the crucible of revolution and the quest for independence. The early American identity was defined by principles enshrined in documents like the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. These foundational ideas included:

The belief in individual liberty: The American Revolution was a revolt against British tyranny and an affirmation of the right to individual freedom. The Founding Fathers crafted a nation that celebrated personal liberty as a core value.

The pursuit of equality: The concept of equality, though not fully realized at the time, was embedded in the idea that all men were created equal. It served as a guiding principle for future generations striving for civil rights and social justice.

The promise of opportunity: America was seen as a land of opportunity, where hard work and determination could lead to success. The frontier spirit and the notion of the "American Dream" encapsulated this idea.

The commitment to democracy: The establishment of a democratic republic set the stage for active citizen participation in governance, cementing the idea that being an American meant having a voice in the nation's direction.

Changing Demographics and Cultural Identity

The composition of the American population has undergone significant changes over time, contributing to shifts in cultural identity. Waves of immigration have brought diverse perspectives, traditions, and languages to American soil.

Throughout the 19th and early 20th centuries, millions of immigrants arrived in the United States, seeking economic opportunity and fleeing persecution. This influx of diverse cultures reshaped American identity, introducing elements of Italian, Irish, Polish, and many other heritages.

The cultural richness and diversity of America became evident in its cuisine, traditions, and religious practices. Being an American no longer meant subscribing to a single cultural narrative but embracing a mosaic of identities that contributed to the nation's cultural tapestry.

The Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and 1960s marked a turning point in American identity. The struggle for racial equality challenged the nation to confront its history of discrimination and segregation. The movement's leaders, such as Martin Luther King Jr., emphasized the importance of realizing the principles of equality and justice embedded in the nation's founding documents.

Today, American identity is synonymous with multiculturalism. The United States is often described as a "melting pot" or a "salad bowl" where individuals from various backgrounds coexist, enriching the nation's cultural landscape.

Evolution of Political Engagement

Participation in American democracy has evolved considerably since the nation's founding. The early years of the republic saw limited suffrage, with only white male property owners having the right to vote.

Over time, the struggle for suffrage expanded the pool of eligible voters. The 15th Amendment in 1870 granted voting rights to African American men, and the 19th Amendment in 1920 extended suffrage to women. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 aimed to eliminate racial discrimination in voting, further expanding access to the ballot box.

Today, being an American entails not only the right to vote but also active political engagement. Citizens participate in elections, advocacy, and grassroots movements to influence policy decisions and hold elected officials accountable.

The digital age has transformed political engagement, with social media platforms enabling citizens to express their views and organize for social and political change. Being an American in the 21st century often involves active participation in online discourse and digital activism.

Challenges and Contemporary Issues

While the core values of liberty, equality, opportunity, and democracy continue to define American identity, the nation faces complex challenges and contemporary issues that shape the meaning of being an American today:

1. Immigration and Diversity: America's ongoing debate over immigration policy reflects its struggle to balance a tradition of welcoming immigrants with concerns about national security and cultural identity. Issues of diversity and inclusion continue to be central to the American experience.

2. Racial and Social Justice: The Black Lives Matter movement, among others, highlights the ongoing struggle for racial and social justice in America. Issues of police brutality, systemic racism, and economic inequality remain at the forefront of national discourse.

3. Political Polarization: America's political landscape has become increasingly polarized, with deep divisions between ideological and partisan groups. Bridging these divides is a pressing challenge for the nation.

4. Global Leadership: As a global superpower, America plays a significant role in international affairs. The responsibilities and expectations associated with this role shape how the nation defines its identity on the world stage.


America's identity is a dynamic and ever-evolving concept. What it means to be an American now differs significantly from the ideals of the nation's founding. The expansion of civil rights, changing demographics, evolving political engagement, and contemporary challenges have all contributed to the multifaceted nature of American identity.

While the core values of liberty, equality, opportunity, and democracy remain fundamental, the expression of these values has evolved over time. The ongoing pursuit of these ideals, as well as the ability to adapt to new challenges, defines the essence of being an American both then and now.

14 September 2023
Your Email

By clicking “Send”, you agree to our Terms of service and  Privacy statement. We will occasionally send you account related emails.

close thanks-icon

Your essay sample has been sent.

Order now
Still can’t find what you need?

Order custom paper and save your time
for priority classes!

Order paper now